1. Elias (b.1886 d.1903)

1. Clarissa (b.~1848 NY)
2. Catherine (b.~1850 NY)
3. Vernard (b.Feb 1853 NY)
4. Mary M. (b.~1858 NY)
5. Seth P. (b.~1871 NY)
6. George (b.~1863 NY)
7. Ida M. (b.~1866 NY)
8. John (b.~1869 NY)

Research of Kevin Everingham 2011;
1870 CENSUS Amity, Allegany, New York ... John Evingham 45, farmer,.. Catherine 43, keeping house,.. Vernard (sp?) 17 male,.. Catherine 20,.. Mary M. 12,.. Phillip 9,.. George 7,.. Ida M. 4,.. John 1.

Burial info Fairlawn Cemetery, Scio, Allegany County, New York.

Circumstantial Evidence: Elias is buried with Philip and it is assumed that this is his father since the 1900 census shows Elias living with John & Catherine, he is listed as their grandson, and Phillip had died in 1900. Also; all other boys of John & Catherine have children accounted for in Census data.